Honorable Mention Top 10 NFL Draft Busts

Andre Ware: T10B Honorable Mention (NFL)

Synopsis: With 4,700 yards and 46 touchdowns as the quarterback for the Houston Cougars, Andre Ware deservedly won the 1989 Heisman Trophy. In contrast, he categorically failed in the NFL with career totals of 1,100 yards and five touchdowns. Following a string of successful Heisman winners from 1985-1988 (e.g. Bo Jackson, Barry Sanders), Andre Ware served as the winner who reversed the trend for the next five years (e.g. Ty Detmer, Gino Torretta, Rashaan Salaam). The following post shows that Ware’s falloff from college to the pros qualifies him as a bust. However, he only started six NFL games so he never really got a fair shot. As such, he earned a T10B Honorable Mention instead of making the actual countdown.  


ANDRE WARE: T10B HONORABLE MENTION

In the late 1980s and early 1990s, two different quarterbacks shattered all sorts of NCAA passing records under the Run & Shoot offense at the University of Houston. The first, Andre Ware, threw for 7,206 yards with 71 touchdowns and 23 touchdowns from 1988 to 1989. The second, David Klingler, threw for 8,528 yards with 83 touchdowns and 37 interceptions from 1990 to 1991. Despite these lofty totals, neither QB translated his college success to the next level. 

After throwing for 4,699 yards and 46 touchdowns, Ware won the 1989 Heisman Trophy. That season, he set an NCAA record for passing yards and fell two TDs short of BYU QB Jim McMahon’s touchdown record. With these impressive results, Ware decided to forgo his senior year and declare for the 1990 NFL Draft. As a bona fide superstar in college, Ware went 7th overall to the Detroit Lions.

ANDRE WARE ROOKIE CARD
Andre Ware
Imagine the excitement of getting this “Gem Mint” rookie card in 1990. Based on Ware’s career, why did someone even spend the money to get this card graded?

Despite his college success, Ware had a hard time getting into NFL games. During his four-year career with the Lions, he unsuccessfully battled for the starting job against Rodney Peete and Erik Kramer. For reference, the Lions had taken Peete in the 6th round of the 1989 Draft and signed Kramer after a short stint in the Canadian Football League. When compared to the quarterbacks on his team or other quarterbacks from his draft class, Ware fared poorly.

NFL CAREER TOTALS FOR QUARTERBACKS CONNECTED TO ANDRE WARE
Player Record Yards TD INT Passer Rating Weighted Avg Value (WAV)
Andre Ware
1990 (#7)
3-3 1,112 5 8 63.5 5
Neil O’Donnell
1990 (#70)
55-45 21,690 120 68 75.3 59
Scott Mitchell
1990 (#93)
32-39 15,692 95 81 81.8 49
Rodney Peete
1989 (#141)
45-52 16,338 76 92 73.3 46
Erik Kramer
1987 (undrafted)
31-36 15,337 92 79 76.7 41

Rushing stats:

  • Ware (217 yards, 0 touchdowns). 
  • O’Donnell (446 yards, 4 touchdowns).
  • Mitchell (485 yards, 11 touchdowns).
  • Peete (1,139 yards, 16 touchdowns).
  • Kramer (217 yards, 5 touchdowns). 

Interestingly, Ware had the same number of rushing yards as Kramer despite having 90% fewer starts.

Surprisingly, Ware only started six games during his entire career with the Lions. In contrast, Peete started 39 games and Kramer started 15 games during the same time span. Despite averaging less than 160 passing yards and one touchdown per start, Peete somehow started almost 100 games and survived 17 years in the league. Yet, Ware somehow only got six starts.

RODNEY PEETE (A.K.A. MR. HOLLY ROBINSON)
rodney-peete-wife-holly-robinson-peete23
Someone outkicked his coverage.

Staying with the Hollywood theme, Kramer could be described best as the real-life version of a football player portrayed by Keanu Reeves. In case you’re stuck, think Shane Falco from The Replacements, not Johnny Utah from Point Break. In particular, Kramer’s only experience in the NFL prior to playing for Detriot was as a replacement player during the 1987 strike.

SHANE FALCO (A.K.A. ERIK KRAMER)
shane-falco
Trivial trivia: Both of the QBs portrayed by Reeves attended THE Ohio State University.

Kramer had better per game averages and a higher TD/INT ratio than Peete. However, the former scab had one incredible season which skews the results. While playing for Chicago during the 1995 season, Kramer threw for 3,800 yards with 29 touchdowns and only 10 interceptions. Excluding that season, he never threw more than 14 touchdowns in any season and his career TD/INT ratio would fall below one.

MITCH ALBOM – IMPETUS FOR CHANGE?

In retrospect, the Lions’ rotating quarterback philosophy probably did more harm than good. Heck, just ask any fan of the Cleveland Browns from the last decade about this strategy.

For a Detroit Free Press article in November 1992, Mitch Albom, wrote about the Lions’ unstable quarterback situation. Many of you probably know Albom from The Sports Reporters. Others might know him as the author of great books that get turned into bad movies. Regardless, he identified the core issue. Specifically, why was Ware (a #7 overall pick) on the bench given that the Lions were 2-8 with Peete as the starter.

Albom highlighted the following exchange with Lions Coach Wayne Fontes in his article.

ALBOM: Do you want to try Andre [Ware]?

FONTES: I could. I might.

ALBOM: So you will?

FONTES: If I do, then we’ll go that way. And it’ll be positive. But I might not.

Wow, how’s that for commitment! Fontes initially didn’t “go that way” and started Kramer for the next three games instead. After Kramer went 1-2 as a starter and the Lions fell to 3-10 for the season, Fontes finally changed directions and decided to “try Andre.”

ANDRE WARE – THE STARTER

Over the final three games of the year, Ware went 2-1 as the starter and put up the following numbers.

  • At home for Game 1: Went 10-14 for 138 yards and two TDs in a 24-14 win against the 7-6 Cleveland Browns.
  • At home for Game 2: Threw two picks but also passed for 290 yards in a 16-3 win against the 5-9 Chicago Bears. 
  • Away for Game 3: Went 15-29 for 116 yards and one INT in a 24-6 loss to the 13-2 San Francisco 49ers.

While Ware’s stats weren’t outstanding, they weren’t too bad either. More importantly, he won two out of three games. For a team that finished 5-11, Ware had 40% of the wins with fewer than 20% of the starts.

Despite Ware’s strong finish to the 1992 season, Fontes went back to Peete to start the 1993 season. True to form, Fontes remained indecisive and continued to use all three quarterbacks at different points of the year. After an injury to Peete, Ware started in weeks four and five. However, he got pulled before even finishing the second game.

  • Game 1 (home): Went 11-24 for 194 yards and one TD in a 26-20 win against the Cardinals.
  • Game 2 (away): Yanked after going 5-14 for 56 yards and one INT in a 27-10 loss to Tampa Bay. Assuming Ware got pulled at halftime, he left the game with a 10-3 lead. 
ANDRE WARE – STARTER NO MORE

Peete returned as the starter after a bye week, and led the team on a four-game winning streak before losing three in a row after another bye week. In the final loss of the streak, Peete threw four picks (including a pick-six) before getting injured. Coming off the bench, Ware threw a pick of his own, but he certainly couldn’t be blamed for the loss.

Presumably unimpressed by Ware, Fontes went to Kramer as the starter for the next game. With Kramer under center, the Lions ended the regular season by going 3-1 before losing to the Packers in the playoffs. Realizing that the experiment failed, the Lions didn’t keep any of their quarterbacks after the season.

Without any other NFL teams interested in him, Ware went on to play in the Canadian Football League and NFL Europe. As the following table shows, he wasn’t any more successful in those situations either.

ANDRE WARE – STATS FROM THE CFL AND NFL EUROPE
League Games Comp Att Yards TD INT Passer Rating
CFL 29 134 252 1,542 10 10 68.6
NFL – Europe 10 54 121 715 4 4 71.5

Ware clearly underperformed as a professional. Still, he had the credentials to get more than six starts. Well, he certainly deserved a better opportunity given that he lost out to two mediocre quarterbacks.

Perhaps Ware never would have become an effective NFL quarterback. Still, he didn’t get a legitimate chance to prove it one way or the other. As a result, he has been given the Rich Campbell Exemption and only gets a T10B Honorable Mention.

ANDRE WARE: T10B HONORABLE MENTION

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.